Who wins: Sabathia/Trumbo for Garza/Beltran/Rizzo

[Knights]

6x6 H2H keeper league.

Team A gets
CC Sabathia and Mark Trumbo

Team B gets
Matt Garza, Carlos Beltran and Anthony Rizzo

Trumbo's red hot, but bound to cool down. Beltran has age going against him but has been a fairly steady high-end producer all season. Rizzo is the big-hype procpect this season, and seems destined for a call-up any day now looking to replicate his minor league numbers at the big league level.

Is this a fair deal? Or does replacing Garza with Cueto or Shields make a difference?

[Element]

Removed Rizzo and it's a fair deal, IMO. I prefer the RIzzo side myself, but it all depends on the makeup of your roster and if the trade makes sense for you.

[Knights]

Thanks - anyone else for a few more opinions?

[WhipperSnappers44]

Txs for the reply....Which side are you? (LOL)

I would prefer the side that has Rizzo just due to the fact that this is a Keeper league and if Rizzo is the real deal and for years to come that he could be a real nice addition.

I do like Trumbo and don't see him cooling too much and I do like Beltran but he does have age and injury about to happen....I do like CC over Garza too but I think the key factor here is Rizzo (even though we don't know yet what he will do in the majors)

So I like the Team A side if the deal was without Rizzo but otherwise with him in there I choose the Team B side...

Good Luck!

WhipperSnappers44!!!

[Ellsberries]

The CC/Trumbo side is less risky. The other deal could pay off big if: Rizzo lives up to the hype, Garza gets traded to a contender, and Beltran stays healthy. But CC and Trumbo are going to be consistent and strong players for a while.

Help with mine:
viewtopic.php?t=449336

[smitty10j]

I would rather have Sabathia/Trumbo, I think there is less risk in Sabathia and Trumbo, there are concerns about Beltrans health but I think he will be ok, and Rizzo is a risk, he didn't do anything for the Padres last year, he has a ton of potential, but sometimes that just never develops, and for that reason I would want to have Sabathia and Trumbo


Help me out
viewtopic.php?t=449334

[midwestpatsfan]

I like the trumbo/sabathia side myself, but that is just me.
Thanks for looking at mine.

[RyeWhiskey]

I like team B's side by quite a bit at the moment. Replace Garza with one of the other two and I'd rather have side A.

[StealingHome]

I would rather have Sabathia/Trumbo, I think there is less risk in Sabathia and Trumbo, there are concerns about Beltrans health but I think he will be ok, and Rizzo is a risk, he didn't do anything for the Padres last year, he has a ton of potential, but sometimes that just never develops, and for that reason I would want to have Sabathia and Trumbo

Thanks for help with mine.

I agree with the following. But I don't know what the rest of your team looks like or who you may be wanting to keep.