My Reddick + J Zimmerman or Vogelsong for Bumgarner

[mayor quimby]

Alright so I can either trade Josh Reddick + either Zimmerman or Vogelsong to get Bumgarner.

Which should I do?

In other words, who should I hold on to, Zimmerman or Vogelsong?

Thanks. Leave a link and I'll help with yours.

[ahcryky]

I'm wondering why you have to throw in a pitcher to make this deal. Reddick should be enough. I think you are giving up too much. What other pitchers are on your staff?

Help with mine? viewtopic.php?f=26&t=449092

[garretterik]

Don't know if this helps, but when Reddick was on fire I was able to move him for Peavy. I consider Zimmerman and Vogelsong basically the exact same pitcher. Decent Ks and low ERA and WHIP. I feel like Zimmerman has more upside, but Vogelsong has been hotter lately.
Help me:
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=449095