Gio for Uggla WHIR 100%

[brianrapp]

I was offered Uggla for Gio. I'm stacked at pitching and have a gaping hole at 2nd base. So, a trade needs to be done.. I'm thinking of trying to go for Kershaw and dempster for Uggla and Holliday.. He has only 2 legit pitchers on his entire team (Gallardo and A. Sanchez) and a plethora of good OF. So, theres a possibility he could accept.
My roster:
My Roster: H2H 10 basic category 12 team redraft league
C McCann
1B Konerko
2B Jemile Weeks/Elian Herrera
SS Han-Ram
3B Lawrie
MI Asdrubal
CI Freeman
OF-McCutchen
OF- A-Gon
OF-Car-Go
OF-Trout
OF-Gregor Blanco
Util-Jhonny Peralta
BN-Middlebrooks
BN-Herrera (also listed above)
DL-Crawford
DL-Stubbs
SP-Verlander
SP-Kershaw
SP-Gio
SP-Lester
SP-Josh Johnson
SP-Wainwright
SP-Dempster
SP-Trevor Bauer
RP-Aroldis Chapman
RP-Fernando Rodney
RP-Santiago Casilla
RP-Rafael Soriano
DL-Chris Carpenter

[MaudDib]

I don't really like either offer but the Gio one is the better of the two. You have nice depth at SP but that is no reason to take a lesser offer.

[brianrapp]

thank you^^^..... some more feedback from others would be appreciated..

[lyons595]

We all like Go Go Gio, but he's probably your 3rd or 4th best SP. You have a ton of depth there...get Uggla while you can. He's a good 2nd half hitter.

[ahcryky]

I like the trade for you. You really need help at 2B and your staff can take the hit. If you can get the second deal to go through....... DEFINITELY hit accept to that!

Help with mine? viewtopic.php?f=26&t=449092

[kaiser]

We all like Go Go Gio, but he's probably your 3rd or 4th best SP.

He's right. Gio is at best your #3 SP. You absolutely make this deal.

[guyincognito]

This is a good trade for you. You fill a need and you have enough pitching to absorb the loss of Gio. I don't know about pushing the Kershaw/Dempster deal because he's obviously trying to gain pitching without giving up any, especially if he doesn't have much to begin with. You may end up shooting yourself in the foot if you go that route, so I'd just accept the deal as is.

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=449091