Dynasty Hosmer/Kinsler for Beltran/Pedroia

[bujfan2030]

14 team h2h dynasty 6x7(OBP, QS, HLD, K/9 instead of K) currently in 2nd(71-53-5)
C Jarrod Saltalamacchia.
1B Eric Hosmer
2B Ian Kinsler
3B Steve Lombardozzi
SS Zack Cozart
OF Josh Hamilton
OF Norichiko Aoki
OF Chris Young
UTIL Mat Joyce
BEN Luke Scott
BEN Ty Wiggington
Ben Devin Mesoraco
DL Evan Longoria
DL Wilson Ramos

SP Madison Bumgarner
SP Anibal Sanchez
SP Jordan Zimmerman
RP Glen Perkins
RP Jason Motte
RP Bobby Parnell
P Greg Holland
P Wilton Lopez
P Randy Choate
P Andrew Bailey
Ben Max Scherzer
Ben Dillon Gee
Ben Adam Wainwright
DL Felipe Paulino
DL Jorge De La Rosa
DL Ryan Madson

Minor League Roster
Wily Peralta
Taijuan Walker
Jake Marisnick
Josh Bell(pirate outfielder)
Oswaldo Arcia

He's offering Pedroia/Beltran for Hosmer/Kinsler
Anybody see any reason to do this? Would you do it if he included Ike Davis?

[aerrico]

I don't see any reason to trade the combo of those two bats in a dynasty league. Hosmer is a guy that is eventually going to figure it out and will be a fantasy stud sooner rather than later. I don't think that you can count on Beltran for this type of production past this season.

[DLRBusiness]

i wouldn't do it either, beltran is old. pedroia and kinsler are about the same, pedroia slighly better maybe when healthy. hosmer should turn out well. and you could probably get a player if ike's caliber in next year's draft or maybe on the waiver wire depending on how your league runs.

help with mine please
viewtopic.php?t=448955

[MaudDib]

No deal. If you could get something better than Beltran then maybe but right now there is no incentive for you to do this deal.