Three For Five trade

[taylor2459]

Hey guys a guy in my fantasy league(H2H) keeps offering me this trade, I think it's a horrible deal for me, I'm just looking for some agreement.

I receive:
Jason Bay
Kelly Johnson
Bryan LaHair
Chris Young
Carlos Santana

I Give Up:
Adam Dunn
Ian Kinsler
Andrew McCutchen


my line up is as followed:

Here's my lineup:

Maldonado (pick up the hottest catcher at the time)
Dunn
Kinsler
Aramis Ramirez
Lowrie
Mccutchen
J. Upton
CarGo
Quentin

Bench

Brian Roberts
Theriot
Berry
Yonder Alonso
Dirks

DL
Werth
Tulo

Any feedback would be greatly apreciated.

[MaudDib]

Horrible is right. Nice of him to at least throw Santana in there but Kinsler and McCutchen are top 25 type players and deserve similar level players in return.

[NikkiSixx]

I definitely would keep your 3 players.