Trade Cruz for Longoria?

[ripvoiceofmariners]

I'm being offered Longoria for either Nelson Cruz or Mark Trumbo. I'm torn! I'm in a H2H league where batters score points for Hits, runs, rbi's, walks & steals. I've got a decent team but I'm a bit weak at 3rd. I'm a little worried about Longorias injury moving forward but I'm also aware of how injury prone Cruz is.

My Line up

C- Napoli
1st-Votto
2nd-Cano
3rd- Seager
OF-Cruz
OF-Hamilton
OF-Trumbo
U-Trout
P-Angels

Bench- McCann, Heyward, Hosmer, Prado, Baves (p)

Any advice would be greatly appreciated!

[ATLbraves]

I would trade Cruz for Longoria.


Is this a keeper or non-keeper league?

[RubiksCube]

I think i would give either of those guys for Longoria. OF is much easier to replace, and Longo is a very good improvement over Seager. Trout can move into OF slot and then most of your bench options are pretty solid fillins.

[ripvoiceofmariners]

It's a non keepers league.

[ATLbraves]

It's a non keepers league.

Well that makes my decision not quite as easy. But I still like Trumbo's power and upside more then Cruz's for the ROS.

Just dont expect Trumbo to keep hitting for this high of an average.