Lincecum for Reddick and 5th rounder? (WHIR)

[toof90]

Should I do this trade?

I get
Josh Reddick

He gets
Tim Lincecum
5th round pick

is a 5th rounder too high? I thought it was too high.

[BadphishVt]

Not a chance, I don't buy Reddick to hold this up through all-star break, let alone the rest of the season, but if anything you should be the one getting the 5th rounder thrown in, Reddick is playing at his ceiling, Lincecum's playing at his floor.

[ATLbraves]

Not a chance, I don't buy Reddick to hold this up through all-star break, let alone the rest of the season, but if anything you should be the one getting the 5th rounder thrown in, Reddick is playing at his ceiling, Lincecum's playing at his floor.

Well said.