My Roster C - Matt Weiters 1B - Prince Fielder 2B - Howie Kendrick 3B - Adrian Beltre SS - Troy Tulowitzki OF - Josh Hamilton OF - Andrew McCutchen OF - Nelson Cruz Utl - Mike Trout Utl - Kendrys Morales Ben - Neil Walker Ben - Allen Craig DL - Carl Crawford
P - Johan Santana P - Dan Haren P - C.J. Wilson P - Jake Peavy P - Colby Lewis P - Anibal Sanchez P - Ervin Santana RP - Joel Hanrahan RP - Santiago Casilla RP - Rafael Soriano RP - Tyler Clippard
From what I see, your offense looks fine (You, like myself, were wise and picked up Mike Trout. High Five!). In terms of pitching however, upgrades are needed. I'd tell you to sell high on Santana, but now you'll have to wait until his next start to see if he can recoup some value. I would sell high on Peavy and Lewis and see what you can get. Lastly, I would drop Casilla, he's not going to get anymore saves with Reed in the 9th. Try picking up a personal favorite of mine, Tom Wilhelmsen of the Mariners, who will get you saves. If he's not available, try for guys like Ryan Cook or maybe a Cory Wade who will help you with ERA/holds.
Great infield. I think I have a subconscious bias against Prince Fielder for being fat. He's a great player though and if Howie improves that infield probably has to be the best in your league. I love Wieters this season. He didn't hit many flyballs last year compared to the rest of his career, but his HR/FB took a jump. Some BABIP luck and some more fly balls and you could easily wind up with .275 30 90 out of your C spot and you probably picked that up in the 5th round or so, maybe later in a 10 team league. That's awesome. I really think he's going to break out. You know the Orioles think so too with the "long term extension" talk coming from out of them. Great sign they're thinking he's in for a big year.
You don't need to be told your outfield is dank. Filthy dank. You do need to be told to get Allen Craig off your bench ASAP, though. Get that dude in where Morales is. Don't even think about seeing what Morales can do in Safeco over Allen Craig. Allen hit 22 bombs in 119 games. 1B is his home now, if he gets into 140 games your looking at 30+ HR potential. He can mash. Safeco is basically death to a hitter, see Adrian Beltre before and after Safeco for proof. MVP candidate in LA prior, MVP candidate in BOS and TEX after. That's just one example. There's tons. RIP Morale's SLG%.
CJ Wilson is a nice under the radar bounce back candidate. So is Haren, but I'm not sold on either guy enough to want to depend on them like I am with Halladay, Lincecum and Lester who I think are slightly better bounce-back buy-low's. Do not trade Peavy. Cling to Peavy and hope he repeats last season. You need that. Peavy, a CJ bounce back, and some luck with Haren and your pitching could be in the middle of the pack and you probably get a playoff spot. Hanrahan is going to implode in very ugly fashion. Put your closer candidates back on the waiver wire and get some guys like Pestano, Mike Adams, Kenley Jansen and maybe even TBs McGee. I know Rodney was insane last year, but I'm less than sold on him being consistent. Tons of turn over in MLB bullpens from year to year, I like McGee long term way better. Weirder things have happened than a Rodney implosion and McGee is next for sure.
Maybe you can get lucky and Clay Buchholz went undrafted. His fastball is an awesome contact-out pitch and his change up is one of the best in the game. If he stays healthy, he'll be back to his 2010-2011 self that finished just outside the top 5 in the AL Cy in 2010. Look at his last 100 innings. If you can get him off the wire, or trade something more or less fungible for him, you're ok. He'll contribute wins and a low ERA.