just to strengthen that argument, I find Overbay a bit Overrated(no pun intended). His minor league numbers are quite skewed in that he played in parking lots in the minor leagues in the Az Diamondback organization.
Lancaster, Tuscon, and Texas El-Paso are all notoriously good hitters parks. Overbay didn't impress me all that much when he came up and the Dbacks made a good move by giving him up for sexson. The minor league parks are not my opinion but the rest is all my thoughts. Take it as you will and go for Cuddyer.
Forget the man crush. I drop what I'm doing to watch Zack Greinke pitch.