CarGo/Wandy for Adam Jones/CJ Wilson

[alex_bazeley]

Is this trade balanced or am I giving too much? I'm fishing for a pitcher to hopefully make up for Weaver in his absence.

This is my roster:
10 team H2H
C - Mauer
1B - Votto
2B - Cano
3B - Bautista, Trumbo
SS - Alcides Escobar, Scutaro
OF - Holliday, Nelson Cruz, CarGo, Melky Cabrera, Trout
UTIL - Viciedo
BENCH - Lawrie
BENCH - Choo
DL - Sandoval
SP - Weaver, Moore, Beachy, Wandy Rodriguez, Gio, Capuano, Samardzija
RP - Papelbon, Betancourt, Heath Bell

[nomar88423]

Definitely would not do that trade. Yes Wilson > Wandy, but your pitching really is in good enough shape to withstand the Weaver injury in my opinion. This would be more a panic move in all honesty.

[Travmacdaddy]

Jones best days this year are behind him I think so I wouldn't pull the trigger. CarGo will stay consistent all year, he's good and he plays at Coors.

[MadDog36]

Adam Jones isn't finished but Cargo is the easier player I'd want.

[kaiser]

I agree with the above. CarGo is far and away the best player in that deal. Don't do it.

[footballisbetter.com]

Have to agree. A Jones has proven to be a stud, but he isn't Cargo. You pitching is strong and can maintain while Weaver is out.

[guyincognito]

CarGo is the best player in the deal and while I do like Wilson over Wandy, It's not enough of an upgrade for me to deal CarGo.

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=448409