Trade Dempster for Vogelsong(will help)

[BigLen22]

12 man league keeper
Looking to upgrade sp I still got Kimbrel and Rodney
I get
Vogelsong
Fuentes

I give
Dempster
Myers

[jovenparque]

thanks for your input on mine.

i don't know about this one. fuentes is meaningless. if you're in a yahoo league daily, then myers can be started from the SP position, which can be good if you're trying to maximize relief pitcher appearances (to help out ratios or increase saves). anyway, i am a sf giants fan and i love the vogelsong story, but dempster has a higher K/9 and a lower BB/9. seems like your downgrading at closer spot and at sp spot.

edit: i'm not saying k/99 and b/99 are dispositive stats. i can't get into the advanced stats because i am just a general baseball fan, but i know that walks are bad and strikes are good. i just use them as a smell test and i can go vogelsong over dempster.

[kidsilk]

I wouldn't do it. I Like Dempster much more than Vogelsong and like the other poster said, Fuentes is basically meaningless in this deal. Don't do it.

Thanks for your help with mine.

[brianrapp]

nope. dumpster gets traded to a contender before the deadline and gets wins.. his stock will soar. I have him and am holding on to him.

[BigLen22]

Thanks alot everyone i declined the deal. Also when i made the offer i for some odd reason thought vogelsong was about 25-27 so i was expecting a nice keeper possibly until i realized he is 34.