My Weaver/Hosmer for His McCutchen/Vargas

[Roberto Clemente]

Play in a Yahoo 10-team Keeper League. We keep 6 players every season.

Will this be enough? I want A.McCutchen badly. I already have Votto/Morneau at 1B. So...I'm dealing from an area of strength.

IF it goes thru...my 5 Keepers next year would probably be...

M.Kemp
J.Votto
T.Tulowitzki
A.McCutchen
Melky Cabrera
Yu Darvish

2012 Yahoo 10 Team Roto/Keeper League.
BATTERS
C- Carlos Ruiz
1B- Joey Votto
2B- Dan Uggla
3B- Todd Frazier
SS- Ian Desmond
OF- Melky Cabrera
OF- Alejandro De Aza
OF- Chris Young
Util- Justin Morneau
Util- Jose Altuve
BN- Yasmani Grandal
BN- Eric Hosmer
DL- Troy Tulowitzki
DL- Matt Kemp


PITCHERS
SP- Adam Wainwright
SP- Jake Peavy
SP- Yu Darvish
RP- Santiago Casilla
RP- Joel Hanrahan
P- Jonathan Broxton
P- Jason Motte
P- Ryan Cook
BN- Brandon McCarthy
BN- Josh Lindblom
DL- Chris Carpenter
DL- Jered Weaver

[MaudDib]

I think that is enough. Kind of depends on what his thoughts are of Weaver and Hosmer (one injured and one slumping badly) but well worth an offer and very likely could be accepted.

[MadDog36]

Good luck with that. FYI, Melky Cabrera isn't a keeper to me despite his torrid May. I'd keep Uggla over him or try to trade for a better 4th and 5th keeper.

[Roberto Clemente]

Good luck with that. FYI, Melky Cabrera isn't a keeper to me despite his torrid May. I'd keep Uggla over him or try to trade for a better 4th and 5th keeper.

Disagree. Cabrera is Ranked 6th in our League. He is still fairly young. Sounds like a Keeper to me considering we keep 6. Cabrera was once a highly touted Yankee prospect who started to flash last season...now he is really coming into his talent. Hard to argue with his ranking or productivity...not sure where you are coming from.

D.Uggla is on my short list...I might end up keeping him. He is undervauled. He plays a position in which talent is thin.

[NikkiSixx]

Yeah I would probably do this deal if I were you. Cutch is easily the best player in the deal, especially with Weaver's injury.