pick up feliz or carpenter? WHIR

[joeyg2323]

alright so heres the deal, my league has 2 DL spots in the league, cespedes is coming off it tomorrow so i will have a free spot. everyone that plays in yahoo should no you have to drop a player to take someone off the DL unless you have a roster space available. so what i want to do is pick up feliz or carp and put them on the DL in replace of cespedes question is who would you pick up?


WHIR

[MaudDib]

I would probably take Carpenter even though he is at least 4-6 weeks away. But I have heard Feliz might be sent to the bullpen when he returns and with the way Nathan is pitching I am I don't see him taking the closer role.

[converge241]

Feliz is probably safer to come back sooner but for more potential impact have to go Carpenter

[NikkiSixx]

If you can afford to stash him then take Carpenter. If not take Feliz. I dont think either option will hurt you.

[joeyg2323]

I would probably take Carpenter even though he is at least 4-6 weeks away. But I have heard Feliz might be sent to the bullpen when he returns and with the way Nathan is pitching I am I don't see him taking the closer role.

i have a lot of young players so injury isnt a main concern. chipper is on the DL but should be back in a week or 2 and my only other concerns would be quentin and heyward. so if i can wait the 4-6 weeks you think carp in the better choice?

[MaudDib]

I would probably take Carpenter even though he is at least 4-6 weeks away. But I have heard Feliz might be sent to the bullpen when he returns and with the way Nathan is pitching I am I don't see him taking the closer role.

i have a lot of young players so injury isnt a main concern. chipper is on the DL but should be back in a week or 2 and my only other concerns would be quentin and heyward. so if i can wait the 4-6 weeks you think carp in the better choice?

Only because I have heard Feliz will be in the pen. So unless a non-closer Feliz will be useful for you, i would take Carpenter. Could depend on your league as well, sometime those middle relief pitchers that rack up lots of K's are extremely useful. Personally I would take Carpenter and hope he comes back similar to what he did last year.