Please help me. I have been offered 3 trades for my Josh Hamilton. I am currently in 1st place. The first two trades come from the guy in 3rd place and the third comes for the guy in 6th. 1. I get Lance Lynn and Paul Konerko for Hamilton 2. I get Justin Upton, Roy Halladay and Ross Detwiler for Hamilton and Wilin Roasario (this guy is in 3rd place without having a catcher all year!!!!) 3. I get Adrian Gonzalez, Asdrubal Cabrera and Johan Santana for Hamilton, Michael Young and Allen Craig 14 team H2H league
Hitting: R, H, HR, RBI, SB, BB, AVG, OBP Pitching: IP, W, L, SV, K, ERA, WHIP My team: C- Matt Wieters 1B- Carlos Pena 2B- Michael Young 3B- David Wright SS- Ian Desmond IF- Will Middlebrooks OF- Josh Hamilton OF- Ryan Braun OF- Michael Bourn OF- Drew Stubbs Util- Kirk Nieuwenhuis Util- Wilin Rosario BN- Peter Bourjos BN- Darwin Barney BN- Gregor Blanco BN- Carlos Santana (no more DL spots so the Halladay deal may be sort of a problem) DL- Emilio Bonafacio DL- Allen Craig SP- C.C. Sabathia SP- Joe Saunders SP- Derek Holland SP- Ivan Nova RP- Matt Moore RP- Jeff Samardzjia P- Colby Lewis P- Wei-Yin Chen BN- Scott Diamond DL- Neftali Feliz
Should I accept one of these deals, ask for more or just hold on to Hamilton.
I would not do any of them. If Halladay was healthy then I would do the 2nd one. Your lineup must be working for you, but I would try to trade away a hitter for some better SP. You have some nice hitting trade pieces.
10 team h2h C Jesus Montero 1b Butler 2b Phillips 3b Beltre SS Rollins OF Braun, Rios, Craig, De Aza Util Ortiz SP Felix, Bumgarner, Zimmerman, Haren, Hammel, T. Hudson, Lynn, Gee RP Jansen, Reed, Cook, Santos DL
I agree that none of these trades are good because of the Halladay injury. Maybe ask for Upton, Konerko and Lance Lynn for Hamilton, Rosario and Young. Otherwise I think based on these offers I'd hold on to hamilton and keep reaping the benefits of his monster hitting.