Trade Bauer for Josh Johnson or Johan Santana?

[famtasy]

Someone is willing to trade me Josh Johnson or Johan Santana for Bauer. Should I do it, and who should I choose? JJ or JS?

[jcave24]

Not sure as to the setup of your league... If this is a keeper league and you're looking to compete, I'd do it for Johnson and hope for him to stay healthy. If this is a deep keeper league and you're looking to build for the future, hold onto Bauer.

If its a one year league, trade for Johnson and, again, hope for the best. I don't think Bauer will be all that impactful this year. He's been walking more than his share of batters in the minors.

[famtasy]

League setup: keep 3.
mostly looking to compete this year, but also want to build for the future.

[jcave24]

I wouldn't suggest keeping him in that format anyway, and as I said, I don't think he'll be all that effective this year anyhow.

I'd say Josh Johnson, but pick whichever you think is the better of the two and make the deal.

[ron paul for pres]

Take Santana. Aside from a couple of bad starts, he's been great this year. Take the established over the potential.

[brila777]

Yeah im leaning santana, JJ scares me a bit although much better lately.

Check this out viewtopic.php?f=26&t=448021