Funston's (RJforlife's) Big Board

[Saltydog]

I have a hard time arguing with math and...

I DO have a hard time putting Jake Peavy in a Top 50 if he's only listed by one of five people, but there must be a way to make it work.

[dannahann]

I realize it is probably too late to adjust but I posted mine before the long weekend (and before Hallady's injury). Is there time to remove Doc from my 50 and bump everyone below him up one notch. If so please finish out by adding Beltran to the bottom at #50.

[Saltydog]

Rankings will be released shortly. An update will be made in approximately two weeks.

Doc's issue will certainly be reflected in the next rankings.

[bigh0rt]

It sounds like you guys need to decide whether you're making your own list or compiling everybody else's. It sounds like you're trying to do a combination of the two, which I think is a poor idea. I'd either make a Top 50 between the two of you (or individually, whatever) or figure out how you're going to compile everybody else's without your own biases, which sound like they're coming into play...

[Saltydog]

This is rj's baby. He'll be posting a Top 50 with comments, and I'll be posting a spreadsheet of composite rankings with submissions by users to reflect changes.

I may have gotten a little overzealous being back to civilization after 48 hours in the woods of New Hampshire.

[jfg]

When do you want the next set of rankings by?

[Saltydog]

I've already been playing around with my adjustments so far. Probably around the end of the week or early next week.

Every two weeks is a decent barometer.

[rjforlife]

Probably start gathering this weekend and have another one up by next Wednesday. Looking forward to the changes and seeing who's in and who's out.

[rjforlife]

Who's up for another go around this year? I'm thinking we could start gathering names of who wants to put one together this week and then get lists in and have one up before the end of the month.

[Saltydog]

I'm on board with submitting a Top 50 list with comments.

I will dust off a spreadsheet as well.