Quick trade help. WHIR

[clarkw267]

Offer has changed slightly. Should I accept?

I give: Billy Butler and Casilla

I get: Brandon Phillips

12 Team H2H league, Standard 5 x 5 scoring, Non Keeper, Weekly Roster Changes
C - Santana
1B - A Gonz
2B - Ackley
SS - Jeter
3B - Wright
CI - Lawrie
MI - Walker
OF - J Upton
OF - Pence
OF - Trout
OF - Dirks
Util - Butler
BN - Jennings (DL)
BN - Middlebrooks
BN - J Montero

P - Cain
P - Peavy
P - Wainwright
P - Beachy
P - Josh Johnson
P - League
P - A Reed
P - Casilla
BN - D Hudson (DL)

[akotin]

id say no. Im not the biggest fan of philips and i don't believe his production will eclipse butler in a drastic way.

[RubiksCube]

I would not accept this. I really like Butler this year, and think production between him and phillips could be close to equal, maybe even in butler's favor. On top of that, giving a stud closer in casilla seems like way too much.

[guyincognito]

I actually like Ackley to continue to improve as the year goes on, so I don't see a need to push for Phillips. I'd prefer to stick with Butler.

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=447641

[clarkw267]

Gotta make a decision on this within the next half hour. Need opinions. Leave a link!

[Knights]

I don't like this deal for you either. Butler should continue to produce at a decent clip the rest of the way and Casilla is really running with the closer's gig. I'd stick with what you have.\

Here's mine: viewtopic.php?t=447585

[MadDog36]

For those two I'd go after Kinsler or Uggla.

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=447442

[Conrax]

I would stay put, Casilla has done well in the closer slot and butler should continue to produce and I like both of them combine better then phillips.

[clarkw267]

I don't value closers too much in this league because it's a weekly H2H league. Also there are guys like Thayer, Capps, and Fuentes available on the FA market. Does that change opinions at all?

[sigriffey]

I don't value closers too much in this league because it's a weekly H2H league. Also there are guys like Thayer, Capps, and Fuentes available on the FA market. Does that change opinions at all?

If your league is like mine, where a few teams have a bunch of closers such that you have an all or nothing thing going with them, then I would similarly undervalue closers and take Philips here.