Beltre Reyes or Verlander? WHIR

[rich16979]

Yahoo 12 team standard 5x5 rotisserie league; I was offered Verlander for Beltre and Reyes for Beltre. Which deal would you do? My biggest deficiences are SB, Avg, and WHIP right now, but I am concerned that my staff lacks a true ace. What do you think?
C:Arencibia
1b:Yonder Alonso
2b:Uggla
3b:Beltre
ss: Brian Dozier
OF:Jose Bautista
OF:Andrew McCutchen
OF:Shane Victorino
Util:David Ortiz
Util:Matt Holliday
BN:Mike Moustakas
BN:Everth Cabrera

SP:Matt Garza
SP:Carlos Zambrano
RP:Brandon League
RP:Fernando Rodney
P:Steve Cishek
P:Tim Collins
P:Scott Downs
P:James Mcdonald
BN:Yovani Gallardo
BN:Vance Worley
BN:Ervin Santana
DL:Daniel Hudson

[AlecAdvice]

It looks like your biggest need might be Reyes, but I think Verlander is the much better overall player.

Id take Verlander and then worry about sb's after.

viewtopic.php?t=447473

[rjforlife]

I would take Verlander for Beltre in a flash. It's simple too much value to pass up. Reyes is just a speedball, he doesn't offer across the board numbers like Verlander does in pitching.

[jonboycubs]

All the way, take Verly for sure

[redkanefox2009]

Verlander for sure, he is a rock in any rotation and is guaranteed to be a great pitcher for the whole year. Take that in a second.

Help on mine please? viewtopic.php?f=26&t=447488

[guyincognito]

You have to take Verlander. You can worry about the other categories later, but Verlander is a stud, if not the best pitcher in baseball right now. Jump on it.

Help me?: viewtopic.php?f=26&t=447492