Axford, Desmond, 2? (WHIR) for Josh Reddick, Alvarez, 4?

[toof90]

what do you guys think about this

Im middle of the pack, literally. 6th best in 12 team league
rotisserie

I get
Josh Reddick
Henderson Alvarez
4th round pick next year

for
John Axford
Ian Desmond
2nd round pick next year

I would put reddick in the Utility role where currently I have Desmond at. who is doing ok

My batters
C Molina
1B Teixeira
2B Uggla
3B Hanley Ramirez
SS Starlin Castro
OF Adam Jones
OF Chris Young
OF Melky Cabrera
Util Freese
Util Desmond
bnch: Montero and De Aza

My pitchers are
James Shields
Roy Halladay
Edinson Volquez
Ryan Dempster
Josh Beckett
Bass
Hanson
Zombrano
Dickey

[toof90]

bump

[weareallkipnises]

I probably wouldn't make the trade. I like the way Desmond is playing this year. And with what's been going on with closers this year, a great closer with as secure of a job as you can get is a great asset to have.

Thanks for the help on mine.

[AlecAdvice]

in terms of players the Reddick side certainly has more upside, but I dont think the drop from the 2nd to 4th round is worth that.

If it was 8th to 10th or something I would consider it, but a 2nd rounder is just too valuable compared to a 4th.

viewtopic.php?t=447473

[rjforlife]

There just isn't much value for you here. You are totally gambling on Reddick staying hot, and you have nothing to fall back on because you are on the losing end of the draft pick swap. I wouldn't take this deal.