My Cain/Smyly for his Halladay/McCarthy WHIR

[sigriffey]

Should I accept this deal? My main concern interest is whether my team is better off with Cain or Halladay.

The offer--
I give Matt Cain and Drew Smyly.
I get Roy Halladay and Brandon McCarthy

12 Team H2H DAILY LEAGUE with 6 Keepers Season to Season, each for 3 years max. * means a keeper entering this season
Stat Categories: R, 1B, 2B, 3B, HR, RBI, SB, BB, AVG -- IP, CG, W, L, ER, ERA, K, SV, WHIP


MY CURRENT TEAM

C Jesus Montero
1B Prince Fielder*
2B Dustin Pedroia*
3B Miguel Cabrera*
SS Hanley Ramirez*
OF Curtis Granderson
OF Hunter Pence
OF Giancarlo Stanton
UT Adam Dunn
UT Eric Hosmer
UT Emilio Bonifacio
BN Jason Kubel
DL Jacoby Ellsbury
DL Carl Crawford

SP Clayton Kershaw
SP Cole Hamels
SP Matt Cain
RP Chris Sale
RP Aroldis Chapman
P Brandon Beachy
P Jordan Zimmermann
P Ricky Romero
BN Erik Bedard
BN Drew Smyly
BN Jarrod Parker
DL Sergio Santos
DL David Robertson

[MaudDib]

I would do that. I prefer Halladay to Cain and McCarthy to Smyly.