Holiday/J.Upton Furcal for CarGo

[taylor2459]

Hi there I play in the MLB fantasy leagues and have been offered CarGo for Holliday/J.Upton and Furcal. I'm leaning more towards Upton because I don't believe he's going to repeat his numbers from last year.

my team:

C Weiters
1B Dunn
2B Kinsler
3B Aramis Ramirez
SS Tulo
OF Holiday
OF Dirks
OF J. Upton
U Furcal

Bench:

Domit
Butler
Rasmus
Yonder Alonzo
Brian Dozier
Werth DL

any help would be appreciated.


Thanks

[MaudDib]

I would do this deal if you traded Holliday but not Upton. I think Upton will finish with better numbers than Cargo but I am not sold that Holliday will be in the same tier as Cargo or Upton.

[mrbohjangles]

I would do this deal if you traded Holliday but not Upton. I think Upton will finish with better numbers than Cargo but I am not sold that Holliday will be in the same tier as Cargo or Upton.

I agree. Don't give up on Upton just yet.

viewtopic.php?t=447297

[joeyg2323]

I would do this deal if you traded Holliday but not Upton. I think Upton will finish with better numbers than Cargo but I am not sold that Holliday will be in the same tier as Cargo or Upton.

[OBPlover]

Is this Roto or H2h and what are the categories?