2X1 TRADE- Should I pull the trigger??

[El Coronita]

14 teams, Roto, 2 keepers league.
Im currently in 3rd place and I need SV's, ERA and WHIP.

He's offering a 2x1
my JOSH HAMILTON and his HUNTER PENCE/FERNANDO RODNEY...
Should I do it? or ask for Jim Johnson? or maybe ask for both (rodney/johnson vs hamilton)? HELP!!!

MY team:
Carlos Santana (Keeper)
Bryan LaHair
Jose Altuve
Kyle Seager
JJ Hardy
Josh Hamilton
Bryce Harper
Tony Campana
Cody Ross
A.J Ellis
Aramis Ramirez
Rickie Weeks
Nick Swisher
Jed Lowrie
Carl Crawford (DL)

Tim Lincecum (Keeper)
Zack Greinke
Matt Capps
Steve Cishek
Jeff Samardzija
Lance Lynn
Tim Stauffer
Johnny Cueto
Drew Storen (DL)

His Team
Joe Mauer
Dunn
Neil Walker
Martin Prado
Alexei Ramirez
Hunter Pence
Matt Holliday
Angel Pagan
Corey Hart
Gerardo Parra
Chipper Jones
Jon Jay
Brennan Boesch
Michael Morse

Cliff Lee
Jason Vargas
Jason Motte
Rafael Betancourt
Kenley Jansen
Jim Johnson
Brett Myers
Fernando Rodney
CC Sabathia
Yovani Gallardo
Vance Worley

[Martain]

I don't think I would trade Josh Hamilton for anyone right now...

I would sell high on LaHair and see if you can get a good starter from him.

[mtrain42]

If you do this, a somewhere a baby will cry

[MadDog36]

NOT A CHANCE!
C Carlos Santana (Keeper)
1b Bryan LaHair
2b Jose Altuve
MI Rickie Weeks
3b Kyle Seager (GREAT PICK HERE!)
CI Aramis Ramirez
SS JJ Hardy
OF Josh Hamilton. Bryce Harper, Tony Campana. Cody Ross. A.J Ellis
UTL Nick Swisher, Jed Lowrie
Carl Crawford DL

Offer him Hamilton ask for his Pence and Sabathia

[El Coronita]

NOT A CHANCE!
C Carlos Santana (Keeper)
1b Bryan LaHair
2b Jose Altuve
MI Rickie Weeks
3b Kyle Seager (GREAT PICK HERE!)
CI Aramis Ramirez
SS JJ Hardy
OF Josh Hamilton. Bryce Harper, Tony Campana. Cody Ross. A.J Ellis
UTL Nick Swisher, Jed Lowrie
Carl Crawford DL

Offer him Hamilton ask for his Pence and Sabathia

Awesome! ! but i need a good RP to get me SV's!

[pangbones]

It's not a bad offer. I think you could still get a little more than that for Hamilton. I'd defintiely ask for both RP's and see if he bites.

Heres mine
viewtopic.php?t=447282

[ROC AllStars]

It's not a bad offer. I think you could still get a little more than that for Hamilton. I'd defintiely ask for both RP's and see if he bites.

Agreed. Still, I would go for an established ace. Closers are too volatile to justify trading Hamilton. I would look for something more solid, and tool around the WW looking for saves.

Help?
viewtopic.php?t=447278

[pungent]

It's not a bad offer. I think you could still get a little more than that for Hamilton. I'd defintiely ask for both RP's and see if he bites.

Agreed. Still, I would go for an established ace. Closers are too volatile to justify trading Hamilton. I would look for something more solid, and tool around the WW looking for saves.

Help?
viewtopic.php?t=447278

Agree with this here. Move LaHair for a RP, Kimbrel maybe?

Help viewtopic.php?t=447276

[pjtroy34]

NOT A CHANCE!
C Carlos Santana (Keeper)
1b Bryan LaHair
2b Jose Altuve
MI Rickie Weeks
3b Kyle Seager (GREAT PICK HERE!)
CI Aramis Ramirez
SS JJ Hardy
OF Josh Hamilton. Bryce Harper, Tony Campana. Cody Ross. A.J Ellis
UTL Nick Swisher, Jed Lowrie
Carl Crawford DL

Offer him Hamilton ask for his Pence and Sabathia

Completely agree. To trade Hamilton right now you need blue chippers, not closers.
Why not try Hamilton and Lahair for Pence, CC, and the closer you prefer. I'd feel much better about this if you are dead set on getting saves.

Mine?
viewtopic.php?t=447280