Trade proposed to me

[allen730877]

I give Votto, McCutchen, Halladay for Pujols, Victorino, J. Parker and Morrow

12 team H2H Dynasty League.

I feel as if I am giving way too much for Pujols who I have no faith in at all. The rest I wouldn't mind having but he is wanting way too much. Your thoughts?


My Team - http://games.espn.go.com/flb/clubhouse? ... sonId=2012


His Team - http://games.espn.go.com/flb/clubhouse? ... sonId=2012

[dannahann]

Easy decision. Reject this ripoff or couinter with something significantly smaller that doesn't include Pujols on his end. Even if Pujols were putting up numbers like 5 years ago this would be asking too much. Go small after Parker, he's the one you want in your dynasty setup. Don't move Votto and Cutch unless you are getting commensurate talent/upside at a similar/younger age.

[dannahann]

my last reply was doubled here for some reason, any way to delete those?

[MaudDib]

Horrible trade for you.

Votto and Pujols are about even
McCutchen is better than Victorino
Halladay is light years ahead of Parker and Morrow

Not even worth a counter offer.

[allen730877]

Now he offers me Pujols, Austin Jackson and Andy Dirks for Votto and McCutchen. I really don't know what to do for this kid.