Morales and Robertson for Moustakas and W. Davis?(WHIR)

[kidsilk]

AL-only league, 12 teams, 5x5 roto style, redraft league.

Been offered Kendrys Morales and David Robertson(or Matt Thornton or Grant Balfour) for my Mike Moustakas and Wade Davis. Is it worth doing this deal for Morales and one of these potential closers? If so which reliever would you pick? THe only problem is I would have to pick up Gimenez or Valencia off the WW to take 3B place. What do you think?

My Team:

C-Arrencibia
C-Cervelli
1B-Prince
2B-Cano
3B-Moustakas
SS-Y. Escobar
MI-Plouffe
CI-Callaspo
OF-Cespedes
OF-Cruz
OF-Jennings
OF-Smith
OF-Sweeney
U-Vlad

P-W. Davis
P-Sabathia
P-Chen
P-Feliz
P-Lewis
P-L. Perez
P-Pettitte
P-E. Santana
P-Wilk

[kidsilk]

His Team:

C Doumit, Ryan
C Suzuki, Kurt
1B Teixeira, Mark
2B Johnson, Kelly
3B Nix, Jayson
SS Aybar, Erick
MI Getz, Chris
CI Morales, Kendrys
OF Avery, Xavier
OF Davis, Rajai
OF Murphy, David
OF Reddick, Josh
OF Span, Denard
U Ortiz, David
Pujols, Albert

P Balfour, Grant
P Cook, Ryan
P Danks, John
P Floyd, Gavin
P Perkins, Glen
P Robertson, David
P Smyly, Drew
P Strop, Pedro
P Thornton, Matt

[mrbohjangles]

I would rather have Moustakas. Stay put

[ATLbraves]

I think you should stay put as well. Especially since Robertson is injured, and Balfour is no longer the closer. And Thornton is in a closer by committee.




help with mine please:
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=447086

[kidsilk]

Should I propose a counter or just hold off? If so who should I counter with?

[Tutuola]

stick with what you have.

its not enough

[ATLbraves]

I honestly dont see anything on his team that would be worth Moustakas other then Ortiz. But even then, I dont like the idea of you having to grab Gimenez or Valencia off the WW to replace your 3B. And his pitching is def nothing special.




Thanks for the help with mine.

[joeyg2323]

stay put

[RyeWhiskey]

You need to stay put given the WW situation for 3B. Moose is, especially in an AL-only league, very valuable and I wouldn't be looking to trade him unless the value was greatly in my favor. Thanks for the help with mine.

[chillbro]

thanks for the help on mine, if i were you i'd stick with moustakas you dont really need to make the trade and youd be out a third baseman