Should I do this trade? WHIR

[trl1020]

It's 11 team 5x5 roto.

I'd get Roy Halladay and Prince Fielder.

I give up Josh Hamilton, Ricky Nolasco, and Alfredo Aceves.

If you want help back, post a link. Thanks.

[trl1020]

Anyone Please? I have a pending trade offer, and don't want to wait too long. Thanks.

[Lockout]

I'd probably take it, I think you're getting good value for Hamilton. You just have to weigh if you can afford the dip in average that you'll see with Fielder. Halladay is a nice addition to any pitching staff though.

[pungent]

Keeper league: YES
Redraft: NO

I think you're getting good value in this trade and Hamilton will regress and he'll get hurt at some point this season.

What's your current line up looking like.