Kinsler for Beachy + Kipnis?

[bayside]

10 team h2h Keeper league:
i just managed to trade Ackley + Broxton to get Kipnis from an owner who was desperate for saves and has Cano as his starting 2b.

Then another owner immediately offers me Kinsler for Beachy + Kipnis...
so basically Beachy/Brox/Ackley for Kinsler...
do i need to snappity snap accept this one and feel great about getting a top 3 2b without giving up any elite talent??

not sure if it even matters since im currently in 2nd overall and am basically a lock for playoff spot, but:
Kipnis can be kept in the 18th rd next year.
Beachy in the 8th.
Kinsler becomes a 1st rounder, but league rules stipulate i would have to cut him next yr if I want to keep my current 1st rounder, MCab.

intersting SP available on the wire are Bass, Volquez, Miley, EJax

Batters
C: Jesus Montero (C)
1B: Eric Hosmer (1B)
2B: Jason Kipnis (2B)
3B: Miguel Cabrera (1B,3B)
SS: Hanley Ramirez (3B,SS)
OF: Justin Upton (OF), Curtis Granderson (OF), Jose Bautista (3B,OF), Allen Craig (1B,2B,OF)
Util: Brett Lawrie (3B)
BN: Cody Ross (OF), Kirk Nieuwenhuis (OF)
DL: Brett Gardner (OF), Jacoby Ellsbury (OF)

Pitchers
SP: Yovani Gallardo (SP), Cliff Lee (SP), Gavin Floyd (SP)
BN: Jon Lester (SP), Brandon Morrow (SP), Brandon Beachy (SP), Matt Moore (SP,RP), Tommy Hanson (SP)
RP: Craig Kimbrel (RP), Addison Reed (RP)
P: Kenley Jansen (RP), Sean Marshall (RP)
DL: Sergio Santos (RP)

[ATLbraves]

If you think you can handle the loss of a SP, then I think you should make this deal.




help with mine please:
viewtopic.php?t=447044

[bayside]

Thats the question... is my pitching strong enough to do this?

[ATLbraves]

Thats the question... is my pitching strong enough to do this?

I think it is.



help with mine please:
viewtopic.php?f=94&t=447064


help with another thread if you have the time:
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=447044

[joeyg2323]

i would counter with moore/marshall/kipnis for kinsler.

idk how your keeper situation is, but if beachy is on your keeper radar and is a good price your going to be upset with letting him go.

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=447071

[ATLbraves]

i would counter with moore/marshall/kipnis for kinsler.

idk how your keeper situation is, but if beachy is on your keeper radar and is a good price your going to be upset with letting him go.

Very good point.

[rjforlife]

Kipnis is a Kinsleresque player, and the difference between the two is less than Beachy. Counter with a lesser pitcher, or pass on the deal.

[bayside]

I still have the offer open.
I mentioned it in the OP but I can keep Kipnis in the 18th rd and Beachy in the 8th if i choose to keep either.
Kinsler will become a 1st rounder and I would 100% cut/trade him this off season unless MCab suffers some career ending injury.
Im allowed to keep up to 8 players, only 5 of which may be from rounds 1-10.

Leaning towards not making this move now because Kipnis seems like an 85% version of Kinsler, and Beachy is worth at least a half of a Kinsler himself