J.Mcdomald for putz? WHIR

[joeyg2323]

would you trade j.mcdonald for putz?

SP- F.hernandez. lincecum, Hanson, Sale, Minor, Smyly, Mcdonald, Friedrich, Lincoln(stream start)
RP- Kimbrel, League, Chapman, K.Jansen


14 team deep mixed keeper league(keep 4, this is the 2nd year) 5x5 h2h pitchers cats are W, SV, K, ERA, WHIP


WHIR

[felixthecat011]

I'd stay away from Putz. I read an article earlier today on the Arizona closer situation and there was a lot of positives being written about David Hernandez. The way closers have been falling this year, you may want to target a different fireman. Thanks for your help on mine.

[joeyg2323]

I'd stay away from Putz. I read an article earlier today on the Arizona closer situation and there was a lot of positives being written about David Hernandez. The way closers have been falling this year, you may want to target a different fireman. Thanks for your help on mine.

if you can post the link to the article i would appreciate it!

[jruffus1]

I'd wait to see how McDonald fares against the Nationals.

[smoovethug]

I like your staff as is. Good and young. If you can get Putz for a backend starter I would.

[felixthecat011]

The article wasn't online, unfortunately.

But David Hernandez is covered by Brad Evans on Yahoo, down towards the bottom of the link:

http://sports.yahoo.com/news/pickups-of ... pdate.html

[sfjb]

I like McDonald. Putz is 35 and has bot Hernandez and Shaw behind him. Given that, I can see ARI even trading Putz at the deadline if they've fallen too far out. I think you're better suited falling into some saves off the waiver wire.

[MadDog36]

Take Putz man a 3rd closer in a deep league is $$ no worries you can always snag another arm later. Guys like Ernestro Frieri Dale Thayer Dolis come to mind (available?)

FYI DO NOT DROP LINCOLN!

[ATLbraves]

I honestly think you can afford to trade a SP, so this is a pretty fair trade imo.

You just have to pray that Putz can keep it on track this year, or he can definitely lose his job.


But, if there are some decent options on the FA/WW of guys who could possibly take a job soon, I might hold off on this trade and just pray that one of those guys can take the closers role. Someone like Dale Thayer or Frieri.




help with mine please:
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=446989

[joeyg2323]

Take Putz man a 3rd closer in a deep league is $$ no worries you can always snag another arm later. Guys like Ernestro Frieri Dale Thayer Dolis come to mind (available?)

FYI DO NOT DROP LINCOLN!

putz would be my 4th closer and why dont drop lincoln? his going back to the bullpen