Which SS to start? Reyes or Hardy?

[IcarusAdam]

League info: head-to-head points, singles, doubles, triples, HRs, RBIs, BBs, Ks, SBs

Both guys have done well for me so far this year, but I really need to start picking one for every-day use. Reyes has started to become incredibly consistent as of late with his outfield bloopers and stealing bases, but Hardy has the potential to rack up a lot of points in just one night with his big bat and get me those much needed RBIs and HRs.

Who do I go with?

[crashattack29]

Hi Icarus,

I would have to roll with Reyes. He is by far the most consistent and offers you plenty of hope in 2B, 3B, BB, SB and R (didn't see them listed but figured it might not be intentional).

Reyes often times went in the first 5 rounds, maybe higher in many leagues for a reason. Also, that Marlin team is beginning to heat up.

Help with mine please? - /viewtopic.php?f=94&t=446920

Thanks!

[IcarusAdam]

...and Hardy promptly hits a 2-run homer.

But seriously, these two are so incredibly close in terms of point production right now. Reyes is small but steady, while Hardy is slightly inconsistent but can explode every few nights. As of right now, Hardy is leading all MLB SS in total bases, and considering in my league you get a point for every base (single, walk, and steal = 1, double =2, etc.), Hardy has been the bigger performer in that regard.

I'm stuck in an old baseball argument. Who do you go with? Power or speed?