Ike davis or carlos pena?

[metsfan33]

?? who has the better year

[jonboycubs]

Pena easily, Ike is in a big funk, he has smacked a couple of homers this week so he may snap out of it but he has this Valley fever thing. I do not know much about it, but I am going with Pena here.

[MaudDib]

They will end up fairly similar value so it really depends on what you need or don't want to kill. Pena has a ton of power but his BA will be pretty bad. Davis will have less power but won't be as bad with the BA. I would probably take Pena but I don't really want either unless it is a very deep league.