Big trade involving Granderson and Reyes....

[cassplaya4]

What do you guys think of this trade offer I received? I need OF and SP help badly, as you can see in the roster below....

Give: Miggy C, Reyes, Jennings, H Alvarez

Get: Granderson, Edwin Encarnacion, Rollins, Wainwright, CJ Wilson

C - Monetero
1B - Laroche
2B - Altuve
3B - Cabrera, Sandoval (DL)
SS - Reyes, Furcal
OF - Choo, Stubbs, Maybin, Jennings, Zobrist, Gardner (DL)

SP - Kershaw, Price, Lester, Garza, Sale, Lilly, H Alvarez
CP - Betancourt, Hanrahan, Rodney, Robertson, Downs

[TheGuru]

I think you're giving up too much

viewtopic.php?t=446816

[MaudDib]

Not a chance. You should be getting more for Cabrera. I am not sold on EE, Rollins or Wainwright all year. So you are giving up Reyes (who I think will still be a very solid player and way better than Rollins), Jennings (who has been pretty good so far) and Cabrera (who still has to be considered a top 3 player). Nope you are giving up way too much and what you are getting isn't going to help you very much.

[jonboycubs]

Grandy is a great pickup and I would do something to get him, if it were just Miggy and not Reyes too maybe yes, but the others are right, you can get more for Miggy, do not give up on this one just squeeze some more out of him, if he wants Miggy and a great ss in Reyes he will give you what you want, go for another starter