Gio for Cargo?.....WHIR

[jonboycubs]

I GIVE - Gio and Phillips

I GET - Cargo and Drew Smyly

All i have left at 2nd if i do this is Barney, and I am giving up an excellent starter, what yall think

16 team H2H Points / 4 keeper / 12 start limit- Scoring Settings
http://games.espn.go.com/flb/leaguesetup/settings?leagueId=266827

MY ROSTER
C – Jonathan Lucroy
1B-Michael Young / 3B, DH,1B
2B-Brandon Phillips
3B-Emilio Bonifacio / SS,3B,0F
SS-Starlin Castro
2B/SS-Jimmy Rollins
1B/3B-Placido Polanco
OF-Curtis Granderson
OF-BJ Upton
OF-Matt Joyce
OF-Dexter Fowler
OF-Juan Pierre
UTIL- Ike Davis / 1b
UTIL-Todd Helton / 1b
UTIL-Josh Thole / c
B-Darwin Barney / 2b
B-Cameron Maybin / OF
B-Juan Pierre / ss,2b
SP
Madison Bumgarner
Gio Gonzalez
Jeff Niemann
Bronson Arroyo
Chad Billingsley
Ted Lilly
Roy Halladay
Joe Weiland
RA Dickey
RP
Jonathan Papelbon
Sergio Romo
Tyler Clippard

[jonboycubs]

or he has now offered

i give - mike young, rollins, and bj upton

i get - napoli, lance lynn, and reimold

[kaiser]

Yes, it's tough, but I think I would make that deal to land Carlos Gonzalez. The power is too hard to find elsewhere.

[ATLbraves]

I would accept the trade for Cargo.



help with mine please:
viewtopic.php?t=446784

[elvis1074]

Yes, take the Cargo deal

PLEASE HELP
viewtopic.php?t=446791

[BStew]

Definitely yes for Cargo, I would not take the second deal.

[jonboycubs]

It seems the consensus is yes take the Cargo deal and I am close to doing so cause God knows I want him, I may be over thinking this but what I am looking at is...

Cargo is avg 33.6 points per game
Smyly is avg 85.6 per start

while

Phillips is avg 30.8
Gio is avg 110 points per start

I just keep thinking can Smyly keep his good starts up, but then again Phillips may not stay healthy so even though Cargo would boost my OF, Im i just giving up to much in pitching?

16 team H2H Points / 4 keeper / 12 start limit- Scoring Settings
http://games.espn.go.com/flb/leaguesetu ... eId=266827

MY ROSTER
C – Jonathan Lucroy
1B-Michael Young / 3B, DH,1B
2B-Brandon Phillips
3B-Emilio Bonifacio / SS,3B,0F
SS-Starlin Castro
2B/SS-Jimmy Rollins
1B/3B-Placido Polanco
OF-Curtis Granderson
OF-BJ Upton
OF-Matt Joyce
OF-Dexter Fowler
OF-Juan Pierre
UTIL- Ike Davis / 1b
UTIL-Todd Helton / 1b
UTIL-Josh Thole / c
B-Darwin Barney / 2b
B-Cameron Maybin / OF
B- /Cody Ransom ss, 3b
SP
Madison Bumgarner
Gio Gonzalez
Jeff Niemann
Bronson Arroyo
Chad Billingsley
Ted Lilly
Roy Halladay
Joe Weiland
RA Dickey
RP
Jonathan Papelbon

Sergio Romo
Tyler Clippard

[TruYankeeFan]

While I do believe Gio is going to have a career year...I don't think he can keep his current production up all year.

I would do the deal for CarGo

Thanks for the help on mine!

[METS 24]

Deleted

[jonboycubs]

It might work out that he will get bumgarner instead of gio, if i get smyly, or if he wants gio i get lynn instead, so it would be

I GET - CARGO AND LYNN

I GIVE - GIO AND PHILLIPS

OR

I GET - CARGO AND SMYLY

I GIVE - BUMGARNER AND PHILLIPS