Trade for Gallardo?

[dubstar]

I've been trying various things to get Gallardo and the last communicatuion from his owner was this:

I give Andrus/J Garcia for Gallardo/Peralta(ss). Would you guys do that? I don't exactly love Peralta, but his May/June last year were his best months. Should I counter with just Andrus for Gallardo? And hope Aviles is usable this year? Or try to move a different SP of mine in this deal? He doesn't want Minor since he dropped him.

Keeper info, I kept Andrus this year in round 14, and he moves up 1 round each year with no limit on years kept. Gallardo is a round 3 player this year. So he probably wouldn't be kept for me going forward. I just lost Sale as a starter, and have D Hudson on the DL and have no idea how he'll be after returning.


10 team h2h keeper
R, HR, RBI, SB, OBP, XBH
W, SV, K, ERA, WHIP, QS

C Santana
1B A Gonzalez
2B Kendrick
3B Lawrie
SS Andrus
OF Kemp, Bruce, Choo
UTIL Butler
BN Willingham, Aviles
DL Youkilis

SP Halladay, Hanson, Hellickson, J Garcia, Lilly, Minor
RP Balfour, H Rodriguez, Johnson, Sale
DL D Hudson