Pick up Neftali Feliz or Daniel Hudson?

[ron paul for pres]

Both are available. Which one is better?

H2H, 5x5, non-keeper

[MashinSpuds]

I would go with Hudson if you have patience for him to work through his injury. I find that Feliz walks too many guys and is rather inconsistent, plus one doesn't know if he'll hold up for the whole season given his reliever past. Hudson has done it before and, despite the injury, should get typical results.

[MaudDib]

Right now I would take Feliz. Shoulder injuries always worry me with pitchers and it is likely at least 2-3 weeks before Hudson is back in the majors. I would take Feliz but keep an eye on Hudson's rehab. If he pitches a couple more bullpen sessions without problems then I might make the move to pick him up.

[ron paul for pres]

Would you drop Vance Worley for either of them?

My SPs:

Strasburg
Cueto
Garza
Anibal Sanchez
Lance Lynn
Dempster
Johan Santana
Matt Moore
Worley

[joeyg2323]

i take feliz easy here, hudson has a shoulder problem and feliz looked sharp last start.

[ron paul for pres]

So basically, is Feliz > any of my current SP? If so, who to drop?

Strasburg
Cueto
Garza
Anibal Sanchez
Dempster
Lance Lynn
Johan Santana
Matt Moore
Vance Worley

[joeyg2323]

So basically, is Feliz > any of my current SP? If so, who to drop?

Strasburg
Cueto
Garza
Anibal Sanchez
Dempster
Lance Lynn
Johan Santana
Matt Moore
Vance Worley

im not a big fan of worley and plus now phillies are talking about trading everyone and rebuilding so his run support should go down.