Konerko and MadBum for Linc and Votto

[pcm4]

Which side would you prefer. H2H nonkeeper.

[clarkw267]

I would still have to go with the Votto side.... he's going to get hot, and when he does it may not stop for the rest of the year. He's too good to keep producing like this.

[BStew]

Tough call. They are pretty even. Lincecum has the higher ceiling but Bumgarner has the higher floor. I'd prefer Bumgarner for that reason. I'd also prefer Votto over Konerko but not by a whole lot.

I guess I'd prefer the Votto side just a little but It's really just a judgement call.

[MaudDib]

Votto side easily. Linc and Bumgarner could be even but I think Linc will end up ahead. Votto is easily better than Konerko.