Altuve, Lahair, Markakis, Trumbo for Votto, Moustakas

[duberino]

I have been offered Altuve, Lahair, Markakis, Trumbo, and Jason Hammel for Votto, Moustakas, and Morrow. Any thoughts on a counter-trade? This is a keeper league, for up to three years.

My team:

12 Team Keeper League
H2H scoring
Daily Lineup Adjustments
Batting cats: R, 1B, 2B, 3B, HR, RBI, SB, CS, BB, K, GIDP
Pitching cats: W, L, CG, SHO, SV, H, OUT, ER, HR, W, HBP, K

Lineup:
C JONATHON LUCROY
1B JOEY VOTTO
2B BEN ZOBRIST
3B BRETT LAWRIE
SS ASDRUBAL CABRERA
OF DESMOND JENNINGS
OF B.J. UPTON
OF MICHAEL BOURN
UTIL ADAM LIND
UTIL JHONNY PERALTA
BN MIKE MOUSTAKAS
BN COLBY RASMUS

PITCHING STAFF
SP ZACH GREINKE
SP JOHNNY CUETO
SP CC SABATHIA
RP FRANK FRANCISCO
RP GRANT BALFOUR
P JIM JOHNSON
P JEROME WILLIAMS
BN CHAD BILLINGSLEY
BN BRANDON MORROW
BN JAKE PEAVY
DL ANDREW BAILEY
DL CORY LUEBKE


His:

C AVILA
1B BUTLER
2B CANO
3B CABRERA
SS RAMIREZ
OF PENCE
OF PRADO
OF MORALES
UTIL ALTUVE
UTIL LAHAIR
BN MARKAKIS
BN TRUMBO
DL GARDNER
DL S. PEREZ

SP HANSON
SP W. RODRIGUEZ
SP A. SANCHEZ
SP A.J. BURNETT
RP (SP) J. HAMMEL
P C. LEE
P D. PRICE
BN B. NORRIS
BN G. FLOYD
BN D. FISTER
BN DARVISH

[BStew]

No effin way.

Votto is the best player involved by ten miles. Moustakas is just heating up into what could be a great player. Morrow in his last few starts is doing the same.

Altuve is decent but provides no upgrade over what you already have, Lahair could fall apart or continue hitting but no one really knows as he is still very much an unknown quantity, Trumbo fights for playing time, Markakis is decent at best and Hammels has been good for a month.

Quantity does not equal quality.

You would be giving up the best player involved, easily, and probably Moustakas and Morrow are the next best players involved as well.

Pass.

[duberino]

Thanks. That helps cement my doubts. Lahair is nice this year, but very unproven. You're right; Votto is in his prime and heating up. Morrow has been sick lately. I just like to see if anyone has any thoughts on counter-offers, or, in this case, if me even looking at it for more than a minute is a joke. Thanks for the feedback.