Thoughts on two 2 trades - which side wins in a vacuum WHIR

[converge241]

1)

Henry Rodriguez - Lance Lynn

2)

Cano
Asdrubal
Kimbrel

for

Granderson
Tulowitzki
Kelly Johnson

thx leave a link!

[MaudDib]

I think both deals are pretty fair.

Maybe I like the Lynn side slightly more but only because I don't like closers very much (especially this year) and I do like Lynn.

Probably like the Tulo side because I like Tulo more than Cano and Granderson more than Asdrubal.

[dominicfaiola]

First deal: Lynn

Second Deal: Tulo and Grandy side, same reason Maub said.

viewtopic.php?t=446381

[TruYankeeFan]

I agree with MaudDib on both deals (unfortunately, you have to wonder long term about Lynn if/when Carp comes back...but I would still do it).

Thanks for the help on mine!

[weareallkipnises]

I think both deals are pretty fair.

Maybe I like the Lynn side slightly more but only because I don't like closers very much (especially this year) and I do like Lynn.

Probably like the Tulo side because I like Tulo more than Cano and Granderson more than Asdrubal.

[letmehearucaw]

1)

Henry Rodriguez - Lance Lynn

2)

Cano
Asdrubal
Kimbrel

for

Granderson
Tulowitzki
Kelly Johnson

thx leave a link!

1) I like the Granderson/Tulo side. More value from either one player than with Lynn/Rodriguez.

2) Harder call, but gun to my head, I'd still go with Granderson/Tulo side for more value.