McCutchen Trade WHIR

[kirch5]

What would you do?

I get Doumit and McCutchen
I give up Gallardo and Avila

My roster
C- J Montero
1B - Konerko
2B - Kinsler
3B - Miggy
SS - Alexei
OF - J.Up / Maybin / Markakis
Util - Lawrie / A-rod

Bench - M. Reynolds / Trout / Quentin

SP - Gallardo / Kershaw / Wainwright / Hamels / Wandy
RP - R. Soriano / League / Cordero / Betancourt / Cishek

What are your guys thought.

Help me, and I will help you.

[dominicfaiola]

You need OF help and although you give up some talent I'd say do it. Your pitching should be fine without Gallardo and I love Cutch this year. And you still have Montero behind the plate.

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=446381

[chinch sacs]

not a bad trade. maybe instead of Doumit you can upgrade your SS. I had Alexi and he was killing me, I finally dropped him the other day

thanks on mine