A Gonzalez trade

[Colt452011]

I was offered this deal and I declined it. I'm thinking now I should have taken it. What are your thoughts? The guys asked for Dee Gordon and Shane Victorino for Adrian Gonzalez and Marco Scutaro. My team is in my sig and here's his team.

C- Russell Martin
1B- Adrian Gonzalez
2B- Neil Walker
3B- David Freese
SS- Troy Tulowitzki
2B/SS- Marco Scutaro
1B/3B- Chase Headley
OF- Justin Upton
OF- Andrew McCutchen
OF- Jason Heyward
OF- Logan Morrison
OF- Gerardo Parra
UT- Alcides Escobar
BE- Jon Jay
DL- Carl Crawford

P- Jason Motte
P- Joe Nathan
P- R. A. Dickey
SP- Brett Myers
SP- Gavin Floyd
RP- Carlos Marmol
RP- Matt Capps
BE- Yovani Gallardo
BE- Ubaldo Jimenez
BE- Cory Luebke
BE- Chad Billingsley

Now he offered me Adrian Gonzalez, which I need help at 1B and Goldschmidt seems to be sharing a lot of time with Overbay. Should I make the same offer back to him? What do you think? Thanks.

[NikkiSixx]

If it were me I would have taken Adrian Gonzalez in a heartbeat if he only wants Victorino and Gordon. You suffer in SB's but you dominate in overall value. Especialy if Goldschmidt is your starting 1B.