McCutchen & Gamel for Halladay & H. Rodriguez

[CMan0928]

It's a 12 team H2H keeper league. The dollar amounts represent the price the respective team paid for that player during the draft. A players value goes up only $1 per year kept. So, for example, next year McCutchen will be valued at $33 and the year after $34. What do you guys think? I have Trout, Harper, or Fowler to replace McCutchen in the OF. I know Storen begins his rehab next week and will more than likely reclaim the closers job once off the DL, but I'm hoping for a setback and Rodriguez keeping the gig for awhile. Thoughts?

I Give Up

Andrew McCutchen, PIT ($32)
Mat Gamel, MIL ($1)

I Get

Roy Halladay, PHI ($37)
H. Rodriguez, WAS (FA)

[dominicfaiola]

You're basically turning Cutch into Halladay. I love that deal so I say go ahead without seeing your roster.

viewtopic.php?t=445537

[MaudDib]

I personally would rather have McCutchen but if you think you need a starter to win the title this year, then do the deal.