Oh and to add to mine... I would not trade Votto (who takes up my Util spot since I have Pujols) for Hamilton in my league.
but like I said I can't say that's a terrible trade or anything.
Another caveat to this deal, is that Hamilton would be a third round keeper for me next year, compared to Votto being a first round keeper.
Yeah but if he goes to San Diego or San Fransisco keeping Hambone with a 3 might not be as good as Votto with a 1. Also he's got a lot more useful career ending injury risk, IMO. I don't think that sways me much unless he resigns with the Rangers.