McCutchen & Pedroia Deal WHIR UPDATE

[RyeWhiskey]

Take the first trade, absolutely.

[sigriffey]

I agree with the first one being good. It's one thing if Cruz was healthy year round, but he never is. Also, I feel that the law of averages says Ortiz will slow down, ven if he hits .320 he will have to slow down at some point to come into that highly unlikely territory.

[Hopscotch Assasin]

dooo it lol

[Quackman]

14 Team H2H Cats. 3 Keeps
This guy has been shopping McCutcheon and I have a man crush on him and felt why not.

He offered:
McCutcheon
Pedroia

I Give:
Lincy
Cruz
Ortiz
Ryan Roberts


I told him no and he has been trying to make a deal since.

My Roster:
C Soto
1B Tex
2b Roberts
SS Scutaro
3b Lawrie
OF Stanton Cespedes Cruz
Util Ortiz
Bench Lind
DL Utley C. Young

My Pitching consists of: Lincy, Hamels, Strasburg, Sale, Scherzer, Santiago, Betancourt

His Team
C Ruiz
1b Laroche
2b Pedroia
SS Cabrera
3b Aramis
OF Pence LoMo Mccutch
Util Austin Jackson
Bench Maybin Pagan Reynold

His Pitching consists of: Lester, Ubaldo, Papelbon, Clippard, Danks, Peavy

I would love to improve my MI in a deal and this might be the best time to do so. Any suggestions?

I don't get why you said no or why others are saying no. This seems like a great deal. Your getting great value from Ortiz and nelson. Lincy had a good outing but I'm still worried about him. He isn't the same pitcher from 2 years ago.

[islandflyfisher]

Do it! There are far more opportunities to trade down later, if you find you need depth, and I doubt you will have to.

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=445221

[boazchan]

personally, i would do either trade.

help me? viewtopic.php?t=445220