Chris Young for B.J. Upton Straight Up???? Wh!R

[etl1692]

Is the trade even worth it? Is it a wash?

I Give: B.J. Upton
I Get: Chris Young

Batting:
C: Chris Iannetta
1B: Joey Votto *
2B: Rickie Weeks
3B: Alex Rodriguez
SS: Asdrubal Cabrera
OF: Matt Kemp ; B.J. Upton ; Alejandro De Aza
Util: Delmon Young
Util: Brett Gardner
BN: Mike Aviles (3B,2B,SS)
BN: Chase Headley

League: 12 teams, H2H, Points System
Batting: R=1 H=1 2B=2 3B=3 HR=4 RBI=2 SB=2 CS=-1 BB=1 IBB=1 HBP=1 K=-1 GIDP=-1 TB=1

[kaiser]

I think I'd rather have the Upton side, but this is a pretty even deal. Hard to say who would get the better result.

[MaudDib]

I would take the Upton side as well. Add in that Young is hurt with a shoulder problem and I think it is pretty easily Upton. It could sap his power or not not effect him at all but we won't know until he gets back and we don't even know when that is.