I would actually say no. Peavy was one of the best pitchers in baseball and then he got hurt, but now he is fully healthy again. I would roll with Peavy, and I think Kipnis has more upside.
C- Iannetta, 1st- Tex, 2nd- Kinsler, 3rd- Longo, SS- Lowrie
OF- Cargo, Stanton, LoMo, Trout, Harper, Trumbo, Ross, LaHair
UTL- Morneau, Encarnacion, V-Mart
SP- Kershaw, Weaver, Strasberg, Peavy, Holland, Harrison, Nolasco
RP- Paps, Myers, Reed, Storen