Should I give up Josh Hamilton for Justin Upton?

[zyzzbrah34]

Should I give up Josh Hamilton for Justin Upton?

My batters-
C Buster Posey
1B Prince Fielder
2b Brandon Phillips
3d Jose Bautista
SS Troy Tulowitzki
2B/SS Asdrubal Cabrera
1B/3B Adam Lind
OF Josh Hamilton
OF Nelson Cruz
OF Corey Hart
OF Nick Markakis
OF Nick Swisher
UTIL Drew Stubbs
Bench Justin Morneau
DL Michael Morse

[Hopscotch Assasin]

is this a keeper league

[MashinSpuds]

I say it's a good idea for you if stolen bases are counted in your league. As it looks, you don't have much speed on your roster, so Upton should help out a little bit with that. If you can get a little more somehow (eek) due to Hamilton's current hot streak, go for it.

[zyzzbrah34]

This isn't a keeper league.

Stolen bases is a category.

How much longer would it be wise to keep Hamilton? I might be able to buy some time but not sure how much.

[dominicfaiola]

I say ride it Hamilton little longer and with this not being a keeper league I still don't know if I do it. Upton has long term worth but Hamilton has shown if healthy he's an MVP.

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=445020