Stubbs or Scherzer

[rookies and cream]

Straight up. Who would you want? This is a 7x7 roto league that includes quality starts, losses, OBP, and SLG.

[Element]

Flip a coin basically. Though I owned Stubbs for the past couple of seasons in my league where we also use OBP and AVG. It's a double whammy. I generally lean toward the hitter in a situation like this, but Stubbs may hurt more than he helps.

[rookies and cream]

Flip a coin basically. Though I owned Stubbs for the past couple of seasons in my league where we also use OBP and AVG. It's a double whammy. I generally lean toward the hitter in a situation like this, but Stubbs may hurt more than he helps.

Yeah. I'm really just looking for a replacement for Brett Gardner. Scherzer can also be maddening. He's like the pitching version of Stubbs. Flashes of goodness and then lots of badness.