Personally I don't know if I would do this deal or not, probably I would... but I would study long and hard.
Lincecum scares me.. he hasn't looked the same since the [world] series a couple of years ago. Lower velocity? Shouldn't be.. he's young, right?
Considering Boston's start.... Pedroia could be down, but I don't think so with that lineup.. just a matter of time before they start kicking ass. Hopefully.
The other two are a wash.. both will produce expected numbers.
Not a bad trade, but if Lincecum falls flat on his face the rest of this season you lose. Much higher ceiling with accepting the trade, but also a much lower floor.
I would probably accept and take the risk. It is fantasy baseball after all... only for pretend. =)
Take a look at mine? topic.php?t=444724