cabrera/mcann/romero or bautista/santana/price

[hollywood]

ok, i drafted m cabrera in first round and never thought i would even consider trading him.BUT,- this guy sent me a blockbuster trade and im highly considering doing it.i have m cabrera,b mcann, and r romero, he is offering j bautista,c santana and d price.this is a h2h cbs league.should i do this trade -WOULD U DO THIS TRADE ? please please please take a sec a offer a opinion.i will gladly offer my opinion on any questions u may have . thank u so much !!

[bodsquad]

give us the rest of your roster, but I would think yes. cabrera to bautista not a huge difference. mccan to santana not a huge difference romero to price huge difference.

[hollywood]

i was asked to post the rest of my lineup to better have the question answered. so here is my full starting lineup. C-mcann,1-teixeira,2-kinsler,3-m cabrera,SS-j reyes,OF-m holliday,n cruz,m bourn,U- boesch. my pichers are r romereo/c lewis/e santana/m harrison/j jimenez,and i use c sale and luebke as relievers. bench is kuroda/nova/j garcia/buehrle/g floyd. i hope this helps make a decision as to if i should do the trade i was offered. again, its a cbs h2h league,should i do this trade- WOULD U ?? i am begging for some comments here!! thank u so much !!

[chinch sacs]

How many teams in the league? Honestly it looks pretty even to me. McCann / Santana is a wash, Joey Bats is a downgrade from M-Cab and Price is an upgrade.

Is the upgrade at SP worth the downgrade at 3rd? Probably, but you drafted the guys you thought were going to produce, dont trade for the sake of trading. If you think the trade off is to your advantage, pull the trigger.

http://www.fantasybaseballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=444623

[Element]

It just seems kind of pointless to accept, IMO. It's a fair offer, but I think that it's more or less a wash at catcher. You're downgrading your 3B spot a little to upgrade over Romero. I dunno. There's still this part of me that doesn't want to trust Bautista 100%. For that I would probably decline, but wouldn't be against it if you accepted.

[dominicfaiola]

Almost seems as though this is just a trade to trade. The only meaningful difference is Romero to Price and I am expecting a great year from Romero so I say no to this deal. Stick with your squad, looks like you've got a solid team.