Ellsbury/Markakis for Hanson/Maybin/Utley

[Micaelis]

I'm in 20 team dynasty league, allowed to holdover 18 players indefinitely. League is 6x6 H2H, with OPS and holds. Which side do you like better in this trade?

Side A Gives:
- Jacoby Ellsbury
- Nick Markakis

Side B Gives:
- Tommy Hanson
- Cameron Maybin
- Chase Utley

[lane_anasazi2]

I think getting anything for Chase Utley at this point is a win.

[Martain]

As long as Side B has the starting pitching to give up Hansen, Side B wins simply for getting Ellsbury (the best player in the deal by far). Losing Maybin doesn't hurt because you replace with much better, and Utley is a much better baseball player (when healthy) than fantasy at this point...its all about being able recoup Hansen's stats (which is probably difficult to do via free agents in a 20 team dynasty, because I'm assuming guys like Trevor Bauer and Gerrit Cole are taken already)

[OneLoveBoomer]

Some injured goods! But A wins I think.

EDIT: I mean, I'd want Ellsbury/Markakis.

[Micaelis]

As long as Side B has the starting pitching to give up Hansen, Side B wins simply for getting Ellsbury (the best player in the deal by far). Losing Maybin doesn't hurt because you replace with much better, and Utley is a much better baseball player (when healthy) than fantasy at this point...its all about being able recoup Hansen's stats (which is probably difficult to do via free agents in a 20 team dynasty, because I'm assuming guys like Trevor Bauer and Gerrit Cole are taken already)

I'd be the side getting Ellsbury. My other starting pitching right now is Felix Hernandez, Jordan Zimmerman, and Edwin Jackson. I also have Brett Anderson on DL and Shelby Miller, Gerrit Cole, and Jameson Taillon taking up bench spots.