C - JP Arencibia 1B - Joey Votto 2B - Brandon Phillips 3B - Brett Lawrie SS - Derek Jeter OF - Hunter Pence OF - Nick Markakis OF - Torii Hunter Utility - Mark Teixeira Bench - Zack Cozart Bench - Delmon Young Bench - Justin Morneau
SP - Mat Latos SP - Yu Darvish RP - Jose Valverde (closer) RP - Heath Bell (closer) P - Hector Santiago (closer) P - Adam Wainwright P - Jordan Zimmerman Bench - Matt Garza Bench - Ubaldo Jimenez DL - Ted Lilly DL - Kyle Farnsworth
I would keep votto and jeter. Votto is the best player in the deal and jeter will be a reliable ss option who will score a lot of runs. Hanley is unpredictable. At least with jeter you know where you stand. Votto is one of the best players in the game. Hold on to him.