Trade Offer Help

[MattyMcFly]

His Mccutchen and Utley for my Pedroia.
10 team H2H
R, HR, RBI, SB, AVG
W, K, S, ERA, WHIP
My Team:
C: Mauer
1B: Ike Davis
2B: Pedroia
SS:Hanley
3B: Zimmerman
OF: Bautista
OF: Bruce
OF: Boesch
Util: Andrus
Bench:
Bonifacio
WIlson Ramos
Dustin Ackley
DL:
Carl crawford

So, would you make the trade? and if so, who would you drop?
Thanks in advance!!

[GAC8666]

I would say no because Utley is a throw away right now because he is hurt. And who knows what he can be counted on for this year. So IMO Pedoria> MCCutch.

[mpieco]

Ditto. No point in giving up Pedroia for a player with less value and the question mark of all question marks.

I would try and deal though, since you have 3 solid SS's, and an average 1B at best.

Andrus probably carries a high trade value with him for some people, so I'd shop him around to see what you can get. Lance Berkman? Michael Morse/pitcher?

[pjalst]

I would say no because Utley is a throw away right now because he is hurt. And who knows what he can be counted on for this year. So IMO Pedoria> MCCutch.

I agree, this is a Pedoria/MCCutch trade until Utley's status is know.